National Demonstration • Afghanistan - Time To Go - Troops Home Now • London • Saturday 20 November 2010 • More details...

I can't think of a single reason to die for Afghanistan

"I can't think of a single reason to die for Afghanistan," says a senior European diplomat. Meanwhile the rate of British military deaths has doubled. It is proportionately far higher than US death toll and three times more than is usual for "major combat".


By Richard Norton-Taylor
The Guardian
20 July 2010

The rate at which British troops in Afghanistan have been killed has nearly doubled in recent months and is proportionately far higher than their American counterparts, according to the latest figures released today by the Medical Research Council.

The numbers of British military deaths are well above the threshold for "major combat" operations and now match those suffered by Soviet troops fighting in Afghanistan in the 1980s.

The figures, compiled by the MRC Biostatistics Unit at Cambridge, show that the rate of British military fatalities is higher now than at any time since the unit started making records in 2006, the year of the first significant deployment of British troops in Afghanistan.

Tony Blair initially sent 3,300 soldiers to Helmand province in the spring of 2006 and there are now 10,000 UK troops in southern Afghanistan, including 500 special forces.

The MRC figures show that in 160 weeks up to May last year, 152 British troops were killed in Afghanistan. In the 60 weeks since then, 155 were killed.

This represents an increase from 7.4 to 14 deaths per 1,000 personnel years (the MRC's measure, which takes into account the number of soldiers deployed in Afghanistan over a calendar year). While Britain's fatality rate nearly doubled over the two periods, the US rate increased by only about a fifth.

In the last 10 weeks, 32 British troops have been killed, or 17 per 1,000 personnel years, according to the figures. The US figure was just 6.8.

Six deaths per 1,000 personnel years is considered the yardstick for "major combat", Prof Sheila Bird, from the MRC Biostatistics Unit, said today.

Four British troops died within 24 hours in four separate incidents in Helmand at the end of last week. While ministers imply they are confident that conditions will be right for Britain to start withdrawing troops next July, and that all combat troops will be out by the end of 2014, they have warned of a potentially high rate of casualties throughout this summer. Britain can expect an average of two fatalities a week this year, the MRC said.

Overall, more than half the foreign troops killed in Afghanistan in the past few years have been victims of improvised explosive devices (IEDs). But a very small proportion, about 4%, have been killed by suicide bombers, whose victims have been mainly Afghan civilians.

A total of 322 British forces personnel have been died in Afghanistan since 2001, according to the Ministry of Defence. More than 100 were killed last year, twice as many as in 2008. More than 50 have been killed so far this year.

In addition, nearly 400 have been seriously wounded. There have been nearly 650 field hospital admissions so far this year, more than half the result of disease or "non-battle injury".

Oxfam today described the security situation in Afghanistan as worse than at any point since the fall of the Taliban, with donors increasingly making short cuts and relying on "military led approaches".

More than $40bn (£60bn) has been spent on aid to Afghanistan over the past nine years, yet millions of Afghans still lived in poverty, said Ashley Jackson, a senior Oxfam officer in Afghanistan. Afghans were increasingly on the frontlines of the conflict, the agency said, referring to UN figures showing that assassinations of community leaders, government workers, and other civilians now averaged one a day.

See also:
Afghanistan is a catastrophy but Obama and Cameron won't admit it
David Cameron's joke exit strategy for Afghanistan
 

Get our e-newsletter

Email:

Countdown to National Demonstration

More details...

School Students Against the War

26 September: School students meeting in London: Why the War Matters. Open to all school students. Details...

Lobby your MP on Afghanistan

Parliament will debate Afghanistan on Thursday 9 September. Please lobby your MP to attend the debate and to vote for all British troops to come home.

Lobby your MP here...

Anti-War Song of the Week

Masters of War by Pearl Jam
Dedicated to Tony Blair

Tackling Islamophobia

Conference: Tackling Islamophobia in the Classroom.
Details...

MPs speak against Afghan war

Video of speeches made by MPs at the Cut the War, Scrap Trident, Troops Home meeting in parliament on 28.06.10, including by Diane Abbott, Caroline Lucas, John Trickett and Eric Joyce.

Should we stay or should we go?

Former commander of UK forces in Afghanistan Colonel Richard Kemp and Labour MP Paul Flynn make the case for and against bringing the troops home from Afghanistan.


Read the arguments...

CND Campaign

Lobby defence minister Liam Fox online: Trident nuclear weapons must be included in defence review. Details...
Powered By Page_Cache by Ircmaxell